English Teaching: Practice and Critique
Lost possibilities: Reflecting on New Zealand's NCEA qualifications experiment
Volume 3 Number 3 December 2004
John Lovell (Papatoetoe High School, New Zealand)
This narrative is an account of one English HOD?s
experience of reforms in secondary education in New Zealand over the
last fifteen years. In particular, the narrative focuses on changes in
assessment and qualifications. Special attention is given to the recent
implementation of the National Certificate of Educational Achievement
(NCEA), which has now become the major qualification in the senior
secondary school. This narrative argues that the implementation of the
NCEA is changing the culture of English teaching, and cites a number of
concerns: inflexible pedagogies, a lack of debate over issues central
to what it means to be an English teacher, a climate of compliance and
technicist approaches to lesson planning.